Welcome to Sprocket School! This project is maintained by volunteer editors. Learn more about how this works.

Dolby SR: Difference between revisions

From Sprocket School
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
Via the  [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolby_Stereo Dolby Stereo]] Wikipedia page: "The optical soundtrack on a Dolby Stereo encoded 35 mm film carries not only left and right tracks for stereophonic sound, but also—through a matrix decoding system (Dolby Motion Picture matrix or Dolby MP[1]) similar to that developed for "quadraphonic" or "quad" sound in the 1970s—a third center channel, and a fourth surround channel for speakers on the sides and rear of the theater for ambient sound and special effects. This yielded a total of four sound channels, as in the 4-track magnetic system, in the track space formerly allocated for one mono optical channel. Dolby also incorporated its A-Type noise reduction into the Dolby Stereo system."
Via the  [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolby_Stereo Dolby Stereo]] Wikipedia page: "The optical soundtrack on a Dolby Stereo encoded 35 mm film carries not only left and right tracks for stereophonic sound, but also—through a matrix decoding system (Dolby Motion Picture matrix or Dolby MP[1]) similar to that developed for "quadraphonic" or "quad" sound in the 1970s—a third center channel, and a fourth surround channel for speakers on the sides and rear of the theater for ambient sound and special effects. This yielded a total of four sound channels, as in the 4-track magnetic system, in the track space formerly allocated for one mono optical channel. Dolby also incorporated its A-Type noise reduction into the Dolby Stereo system."


 
Dolby A noise reduction is a process in which the dynamic range of a recording is compressed, and then expanded upon playback via a Dolby sound processor. In basic terms, during noise reduction a compressor boosts the quiet parts and reduces the loud parts while an expander makes the loud parts louder and quiet parts quieter. [[Dolby SR]] (spectral recording) applies a different compression and expansion characteristic to each frequency band. Dolby A applies the same one to all the bands. This is part of why it sounds bad when you playback an A-type track with Dolby SR noise reduction. You (or rather the Dolby processor) is applying the incorrect expansion characteristic. The expander does not match the compressor!
Dolby A noise reduction is a process in which the dynamic range of a recording is compressed, and then expanded upon playback via a Dolby sound processor. In basic terms, during noise reduction a compressor boosts the quiet parts and reduces the loud parts while an expander makes the loud parts louder and quiet parts quieter. [[Dolby SR]] (spectral recording) applies a different compression and expansion characteristic to each frequency band. Dolby A applies the same one to all the bands. This is part of why it sounds bad when you playback an A-type track with Dolby SR noise reduction. You (or rather the Dolby processor) is applying the incorrect expansion characteristic. The expander does not match the compressor!  
Dolby A noise reduction is a process in which the dynamic range of a recording is compressed, and then expanded upon playback via a Dolby sound processor. In basic terms, during noise reduction a compressor boosts the quiet parts and reduces the loud parts while an expander makes the loud parts louder and quiet parts quieter. [[Dolby SR]] (spectral recording) applies a different compression and expansion characteristic to each frequency band. Dolby A applies the same one to all the bands. This is part of why it sounds bad when you playback an A-type track with Dolby SR noise reduction. You (or rather the Dolby processor) is applying the incorrect expansion characteristic. The expander does not match the compressor!  


[[File:Dolby stereo SR .JPG|right|thumb|400px|Dolby logo that may appear in the end credits of some films recorded using Dolby SR.]]
===Optical track Identification===
Dolby A is difficult to distinguish from [[Dolby SR]] by sight. Like with [[aspect ratios]] it is best to use multiple sources of information in order to help inform your decision. Such sources include the production year of the print, any identifying labels or text on the leader, or in the credits, country of origin, and production information like whether the film was a Hollywood production or low-budget independent film. Do not blindly trust labels added to the print by other projectionists or even from the distributor!


====Production Date====
[[File:DolbySR Remastered.JPG|right|thumb|250px|A new print of ''American Graffiti'' with a remastered Dolby track. Released in 1973, original prints would have been mono. ]] 
*It's safe to say that any film made before 1975 will be a [[mono]] print. However there are many films released in mono ''after'' 1975, especially foreign titles or films made with smaller budgets.
**Exceptions: There are some cases where mono films were re-released later on with remastered Dolby tracks, but these usually are fairly well labeled and easy to identify.
* Many studio films made between 1975 and 1985 will have Dolby A tracks.
* Some (but not all) films made after 1986 will have Dolby SR tracks, though A-type was still in use well into the 90s.


===Dolby SR vs. [[Dolby A]]===
====Visual Inspection====
Dolby SR is difficult to distinguish from [[Dolby A]] by sight. Like with [[aspect ratios]] it is best to use multiple sources in order to help inform your decision, including things like the production year of the print, any labels identifying format on the print itself, on the leader, or in the credits. Country of origin, whether the film was a hollywood production or low-budget independent film. Here are some tips on telling them apart:
[[File:Soundtrack lab label.jpg|left|thumb|250px|Lab leader identifying a print as Dolby A. ]]  
* First, make sure it's not a [[mono]] print with two [[variable area]] tracks. This is very common. It's safe to say that any film made before 1975 will be a mono print. There are some cases where mono films were re-released later on with remastered Dolby tracks, but these usually are fairly well labeled and easy to identify. There are many films released in mono post-1975, especially foreign titles or films made with smaller budgets. Look at the two tracks closely, with mono prints they will be identical. With Dolby A or SR prints the tracks will be the same in some spots and differ in others. Check areas that have music in them, the credits at the end of the film are often a good spot.   
* First, make sure it's not a [[mono]] print with two [[variable area]] tracks. This is very common. Look at the two tracks closely, with mono prints they will be identical. With Dolby A or SR prints the tracks will be the same in some spots and different in others. You may need to check multiple spots along the soundtrack before you encounter one where they are different. Check areas that have music in them, the credits at the end of the film are often a good spot to do so.   
* Many studio films made between 1975 and 1985 will have Dolby A tracks. If the tracks look different at any point, you can rule out mono.
* Some (but not all) films with Dolby A tracks will display the word "Dolby" - or "Dolby Stereo" rather than "Dolby SR" - with the Dolby logo in the end credits. But be careful, just because you see one of these in the credits of the film does not guarantee that it is A Type or SR. Some films were released as both mono and stereo prints, or a film may have been re-mastered and released as SR but was originally mono. Seeing the logo in the credits is just another clue to be used with alongside other sources of information.
* Some (but not all) films made after 1986 will have Dolby SR tracks, though A-type was still in use well into the 90s.
* Some (but not all) films with Dolby SR tracks will display the words "Dolby SR" or "Dolby SR Spectral Recording" with the Dolby logo in the end credits. 
* Some (but not all) films with Dolby SR tracks will display the words "Dolby SR" or "Dolby SR Spectral Recording" with the Dolby logo in the end credits. Some (but not all) films with Dolby A tracks will display the word "Dolby" - or "Dolby Stereo" rather than "Dolby SR" - with the Dolby logo in the end credits. But be careful, just because you see one of these in the credits of the film does not guarantee that it is A Type or SR. Some films were released as both mono and stereo prints, or a film may have been re-mastered and released as SR but was originally mono. Seeing the logo in the credits is just another clue to be used with alongside other sources of information.  
* Some (but not all) films with Dolby A tracks will display the words "Stereo" on the edges of the film [[leader]].
* Some (but not all) films with Dolby SR tracks will display the words "Dolby SR" on the edges of the film [[leader]].
* Some (but not all) films with Dolby SR tracks will display the words "Dolby SR" on the edges of the film [[leader]].
 
** Note: If you use this information first make sure the leader is original to the film
===Auditory Identification===
[[File:Dolby stereo SR .JPG|right|thumb|300px|Dolby logo that may appear in the end credits of some films recorded using Dolby SR.]]
If you are still unsure, the best way to identify whether you need to play something as Dolby A or Dolby SR is to run a reel and listen. Stand in the room where the film is being played, close enough that you can hear well. It's harder to do this using a booth monitor. Have someone else switch between A and SR if you cannot do it yourself while in the auditorium. Follow the below tips and it should become fairly obvious what is correct.  
====Listening====
If you cannot be 100% certain by using the information above, the best way to identify whether you need to play something as Dolby A or Dolby SR is just to run a reel and listen. Stand in the room where the film is being played, close enough that you can hear well. It's harder to do this using a booth monitor. Have someone else switch between A and SR if you cannot do it yourself while in the auditorium. Follow the below tips and it should become fairly obvious what is correct.  
* A played as SR: the expander does not match the compressor. It will sound bright, tinny, and sibilant.
* A played as SR: the expander does not match the compressor. It will sound bright, tinny, and sibilant.
* SR played as A: Dolby indended SR to be backwards compatible ("reasonably well"). Though the expander and compressor don't match, so it will not sound very good. It's a little harder to identify than A played as SR. It will sounds dull and flat, because you're not getting the full dynamic range of the recorded track. This likely will be more obvious in scenes with music or a lot of sound, rather than dialogue only.  
* SR played as A: Dolby indended SR to be backwards compatible ("reasonably well"). Though the expander and compressor don't match, so it will not sound very good. It's a little harder to identify than A played as SR. It will sounds dull and flat, because you're not getting the full dynamic range of the recorded track. This likely will be more obvious in scenes with music or a lot of sound, rather than dialogue only.  
* Mono as A or SR: you're putting it through an expander (it was never compressed, recorded with 30db dynamic range). This will sound pretty obviously incorrect. Sounds exaggerated, loud, and very harsh.  
* Mono as A or SR: you're putting it through an expander (it was never compressed, recorded with 30db dynamic range). This will sound pretty obviously incorrect. Sounds exaggerated, loud, and very harsh.  


==See Also==
* [[Dolby A]]
* [[Mono]]
* [[Dolby Digital]]


==External Links==
==External Links==

Latest revision as of 19:00, 1 May 2019

Dolby Spectral Recording, commonly called Dolby SR,is a sound format that incorporates a Dolby SR-Type noise reduction process. It is used in many aspects of analog recording but for the purposes of Sprocket School we will be talking exclusively about its use with 35mm stereo optical track prints and 35mm/70mm film prints with magnetic soundtracks. It is a 4 channel format- left, center, right and surround. 

It is the most common optical sound format on films made after 1986, when it began to replace Dolby A

It is important for projectionists to be able to distinguish between Dolby A and Dolby SR because different circuitry within the sound processor is required to play them back correctly. If you playback Dolby A as SR or vice versa, it will not sound correct.

Via the [Dolby Stereo] Wikipedia page: "The optical soundtrack on a Dolby Stereo encoded 35 mm film carries not only left and right tracks for stereophonic sound, but also—through a matrix decoding system (Dolby Motion Picture matrix or Dolby MP[1]) similar to that developed for "quadraphonic" or "quad" sound in the 1970s—a third center channel, and a fourth surround channel for speakers on the sides and rear of the theater for ambient sound and special effects. This yielded a total of four sound channels, as in the 4-track magnetic system, in the track space formerly allocated for one mono optical channel. Dolby also incorporated its A-Type noise reduction into the Dolby Stereo system."

Dolby A noise reduction is a process in which the dynamic range of a recording is compressed, and then expanded upon playback via a Dolby sound processor. In basic terms, during noise reduction a compressor boosts the quiet parts and reduces the loud parts while an expander makes the loud parts louder and quiet parts quieter. Dolby SR (spectral recording) applies a different compression and expansion characteristic to each frequency band. Dolby A applies the same one to all the bands. This is part of why it sounds bad when you playback an A-type track with Dolby SR noise reduction. You (or rather the Dolby processor) is applying the incorrect expansion characteristic. The expander does not match the compressor! Dolby A noise reduction is a process in which the dynamic range of a recording is compressed, and then expanded upon playback via a Dolby sound processor. In basic terms, during noise reduction a compressor boosts the quiet parts and reduces the loud parts while an expander makes the loud parts louder and quiet parts quieter. Dolby SR (spectral recording) applies a different compression and expansion characteristic to each frequency band. Dolby A applies the same one to all the bands. This is part of why it sounds bad when you playback an A-type track with Dolby SR noise reduction. You (or rather the Dolby processor) is applying the incorrect expansion characteristic. The expander does not match the compressor!

Optical track Identification

Dolby A is difficult to distinguish from Dolby SR by sight. Like with aspect ratios it is best to use multiple sources of information in order to help inform your decision. Such sources include the production year of the print, any identifying labels or text on the leader, or in the credits, country of origin, and production information like whether the film was a Hollywood production or low-budget independent film. Do not blindly trust labels added to the print by other projectionists or even from the distributor!

Production Date

A new print of American Graffiti with a remastered Dolby track. Released in 1973, original prints would have been mono.
  • It's safe to say that any film made before 1975 will be a mono print. However there are many films released in mono after 1975, especially foreign titles or films made with smaller budgets.
    • Exceptions: There are some cases where mono films were re-released later on with remastered Dolby tracks, but these usually are fairly well labeled and easy to identify.
  • Many studio films made between 1975 and 1985 will have Dolby A tracks.
  • Some (but not all) films made after 1986 will have Dolby SR tracks, though A-type was still in use well into the 90s.

Visual Inspection

Lab leader identifying a print as Dolby A.
  • First, make sure it's not a mono print with two variable area tracks. This is very common. Look at the two tracks closely, with mono prints they will be identical. With Dolby A or SR prints the tracks will be the same in some spots and different in others. You may need to check multiple spots along the soundtrack before you encounter one where they are different. Check areas that have music in them, the credits at the end of the film are often a good spot to do so.
  • Some (but not all) films with Dolby A tracks will display the word "Dolby" - or "Dolby Stereo" rather than "Dolby SR" - with the Dolby logo in the end credits. But be careful, just because you see one of these in the credits of the film does not guarantee that it is A Type or SR. Some films were released as both mono and stereo prints, or a film may have been re-mastered and released as SR but was originally mono. Seeing the logo in the credits is just another clue to be used with alongside other sources of information.
  • Some (but not all) films with Dolby SR tracks will display the words "Dolby SR" or "Dolby SR Spectral Recording" with the Dolby logo in the end credits.
  • Some (but not all) films with Dolby A tracks will display the words "Stereo" on the edges of the film leader.
  • Some (but not all) films with Dolby SR tracks will display the words "Dolby SR" on the edges of the film leader.
    • Note: If you use this information first make sure the leader is original to the film
Dolby logo that may appear in the end credits of some films recorded using Dolby SR.

Listening

If you cannot be 100% certain by using the information above, the best way to identify whether you need to play something as Dolby A or Dolby SR is just to run a reel and listen. Stand in the room where the film is being played, close enough that you can hear well. It's harder to do this using a booth monitor. Have someone else switch between A and SR if you cannot do it yourself while in the auditorium. Follow the below tips and it should become fairly obvious what is correct.

  • A played as SR: the expander does not match the compressor. It will sound bright, tinny, and sibilant.
  • SR played as A: Dolby indended SR to be backwards compatible ("reasonably well"). Though the expander and compressor don't match, so it will not sound very good. It's a little harder to identify than A played as SR. It will sounds dull and flat, because you're not getting the full dynamic range of the recorded track. This likely will be more obvious in scenes with music or a lot of sound, rather than dialogue only.
  • Mono as A or SR: you're putting it through an expander (it was never compressed, recorded with 30db dynamic range). This will sound pretty obviously incorrect. Sounds exaggerated, loud, and very harsh.

See Also

External Links

Retrieved from "http://www.sprocketschool.org/w/index.php?title=Dolby_SR&oldid=2807"